With just two weeks to go, three-quarters of the teams in the NFL have a chance to make the playoffs. For six of those teams (five in the NFC), the chances are 100%. For some of the teams with work left to do, it ranges from easy (Tennessee) to extremely difficult (Denver, Atlanta). I’ll rank the 18 teams still vying for the post-season in order from easiest to most difficult here in Bracketology format (meaning locks, should be ins, work left to do, on the bubble, and longshots. Scenarios are done with the help of ESPN’s Playoff Machine
Playoff Chance percentages provided by FiveThirtyEight as of December 31st at 11:37 am. Note: I do not order the teams by the 538.com metrics, I ranked the teams based on my assumption of the likelihood of them making the playoffs.
These teams have been excluded because they’ve either clinched or been eliminated.
IN: Kansas City, Green Bay, Dallas, LA Rams, Tampa Bay, Arizona
OUT: Carolina, Chicago, Seattle, NY Giants, NY Jets, Houston, Detroit, Jacksonville
Now onto the list, starting with the one true lock –
LOCKS: Tennessee
The Titans are the only team that isn’t quite in yet, but have every reason to expect to be still in when the regular season ends. By virtue of their head-to-head win over the Chiefs, the Titans still have a shot at the top seed in the AFC if the Chiefs slip in their final two games and the Titans take care of business.
1. TENNESSEE TITANS (10-5)
Remaining games: vs Miami, at Houston
Playoff chances: 97%
The Tennessee Titans have the easiest path to the post-season, either through winning the AFC South or sneaking in even if nearly all goes wrong. There is one specific scenario in which they miss the playoffs, which involves them getting swept by Houston:
1. Lose to the Dolphins and Texans
2. Indianapolis wins out (Raiders, Jaguars)
3. Buffalo wins one remaining game (Falcons, Jets)
4. New England beats the Jaguars and loses to the Dolphins
Realistically, the Bills imploding by losing out to the sub-.500 Falcons and terrible (if feisty) Jets at home is hard to imagine. To add to that, they need Jacksonville to beat the Patriots AND Colts in back-to-back, including this weekend in Foxboro.
SHOULD BE IN: Buffalo, Indianapolis, New England
These teams are in the “should be in” category and not the “work left to do” category as they each really need to win only once against substandard opposition, or in Buffalo’s case, two games.
2. BUFFALO BILLS (9-6)
Remaining games: vs Atlanta, vs NY Jets
Playoff chances: 99%
As always in the AFC East, the fortunes of a team changes when they face the Patriots. Before the first game in Buffalo, vanquishing the Patriots would’ve meant the Bills had an inside track on the division title and a high seed (especially with a win over the Chiefs in their back pocket). When they lost to New England, the sky started to fall – the Pats took the division lead and the Bills were on the very ledge of the playoff race – a loss over the Patriots in New England would do even more damage to their playoff hopes, putting them on the outside looking in, and needing a lot of help. When the Bills won 33-21 in Foxboro, their fortunes changed once again. Now at 9-6 with a divisional tiebreaker over New England, the Bills are two steps away from taking the AFC East again and looking like a tough out in the playoffs. If they avoid a disaster in Week 18, they’ll win the East.
The Bills win the division if:
1. Buffalo wins out
2. Buffalo loses to the Falcons but beats the Jets and:
a. New England does not win out (Jaguars, Dolphins)
On the other hand, there is still a doomsday scenario. The Bills miss the playoffs if:
1. Buffalo loses out and:
a. New England wins at least one game
b. Three teams in wild card positions win at least 10 games.
2. Buffalo loses to the Jets and:
a. New England beat the Jaguars
b. Miami wins out (Titans, Patriots)
c. Indianapolis beats the Jaguars
d. Las Vegas wins out (Colts, Chargers) OR Chargers win out (Broncos, Raiders)
e. Baltimore wins out (Rams, Steelers)
3. INDIANAPOLIS COLTS (9-6)
Remaining games: vs Las Vegas, at Jacksonville
Playoff chances: 98%
The Colts couldn’t have started 2021 any worse, they lost to the Seahawks, Rams, and Titans to start off the season and started the year 1-4. Generally, teams that start this poorly do not make the playoffs. However, after a loss to the Titans brought the Colts to 3-5 on the season, they’ve gone 6-1, picked up wins over the Bills, Patriots, and Cardinals and now look like a team nobody wants to face in the playoffs with an MVP candidate (RB Jonathan Taylor) and a strong offensive line (now that road-grading LG Quenton Nelson is back to full health), and an excellent defense. Along with the Patriots, the Colts own the best conference record in the AFC, and with one win, their chances of getting in are almost 100%.
The Colts can make the playoffs if:
1. Indianapolis wins out (Raiders, Jaguars)
2. Indianapolis beats the Raiders
3. Indianapolis beats the Jaguars and one of the following occurs:
a. Miami does not win out (Titans, Patriots)
b. Las Vegas loses to the Chargers
c. New England does not win out (Jaguars, Dolphins)
4. NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS (9-6)
Remaining games: vs Jacksonville, at Miami
Playoff chances: 94%
After winning seven games in a row, some in dominating fashion, pundits were getting themselves ready for the Patriots to return to the Super Bowl (and usually had them facing Tom Brady’s Buccaneers), as if such a thing is a sure thing when December rolls around (and in the past it has been). However, since taking the AFC East division lead at 9-4, the Pats have lost to two playoff-ready teams (Indy and Buffalo) and now find themselves firmly in the wild card hunt. The Pats have two very significant advantages on their side: a 7-3 conference record which can only be matched by the Colts and Raiders, and a Week 17 game against the Jaguars at home. One thing working against them? They get the Dolphins in Miami in Week 18. The Dolphins have a way of making life difficult on the Pats, especially in Miami, where New England is 9-12 during Bill Belichick’s tenure.
The Patriots can make the playoffs if:
1. New England wins out (Jaguars, Dolphins)
2. New England defeats the Dolphins in Week 18
3. New England beats the Jaguars, loses to the Dolphins and two of the following scenarios occur:
a. Miami loses to the Titans
b. Las Vegas does not win out
c. Indianapolis does not win out
WORK LEFT TO DO: Cincinnati, San Francisco, Philadelphia
These teams all have decent odds to make the playoffs, and would a collapse by themselves and some wins by others to lose their spot.
5. CINCINNATI BENGALS (9-6)
Remaining games: vs Kansas City, at Cleveland
Playoff chances: 82%
Despite the odds being in their favour, the playoffs are far from a sure thing for Cincinnati. The Chiefs come in to the Queen City this weekend and then the Bengals travel to Cleveland to face a Browns team that absolutely pasted them in Week 8 in a potential win-and-you’re-in game. A win in either of those games guarantees the division for the Bengals, which would put a bow on the franchise’s quick and somewhat improbable turnaround.
Here are the division-clinching scenarios for Cincinnati:
1. Win one of the remaining games (Chiefs, Browns)
2. Have both scenarios take place:
a. Baltimore loses to the Rams and beats the Steelers
b. Cleveland loses to the Steelers in Week 17
The Bengals could lose both games and lose the division and still make the playoffs in a few different scenarios where we don’t have three wild card teams with 10 wins or more, though losing head-to-head at home to the Chargers does not help their case in that math.
6. PHILADELPHIA EAGLES (8-7)
Remaining games: at Washington, vs Dallas
Playoff chances: 71%
Since the Eagles’ renewed focus on their run game, they have won five of their last six to launch themselves into the playoff race. Now, the Eagles control their destiny – though with a challenging schedule – and have a number of tiebreakers over other NFC playoff contenders. They lost their head-to-head with the Niners but beat the Falcons and Saints.
The Eagles can make the playoffs the following ways:
1. Win both remaining games (WFT, Cowboys)
2. Win one of their remaining games and at least one of the following:
a. San Francisco wins at most one game (Texans, Rams)
b. Minnesota does not win out (Packers, Bears)
3. There is also a scenario where they make the playoffs with eight wins, though this requires some fancy footwork:
a. Minnesota must lose both remaining games
b. Atlanta must lose to the Bills and beat the Saints
c. Washington must lose to the Giants
The biggest question facing the Eagles (outside of what needs to be done) will be whether the Cowboys go full strength in their Week 18 game. If the Cowboys do not have a shot at the first round bye, will they be concerned with jockeying for position? Regardless of their status, will they go all-out to beat their hated division rivals?
7. SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS (8-7)
Remaining games: vs Houston, at LA Rams
Playoff chances: 74%
The Niners chances of making the playoffs are significantly buoyed by playing the Texans in Week 17. With that win, the Niners would be in the driver’s seat for a playoff spot, regardless of their result against the Rams. There is one specific, yet plausible scenario to watch out for if they do split the final two games.
The Niners can make the playoffs in the following ways:
1. Win both remaining games (Texans, Rams)
2. Win one of their remaining games and one of the following:
a. New Orleans does not win out (Panthers, Falcons)
b. Philadelphia wins at most one game (WFT, Cowboys)
c. Minnesota wins both games (Packers, Bears)
If only the Niners, Saints and Eagles are 9-8 (or better in Philly’s case), the Niners lose the tiebreaks. If the Vikings also finish 9-8, the Saints and Niners win the tiebreaks.
3. The Niners also can make the playoffs with eight wins if no more than one NFC playoff contender finishes with nine wins and Washington does not win out.
ON THE BUBBLE: LA Chargers, Miami, New Orleans, Las Vegas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Pittsburgh, Cleveland
Teams on the bubble either need some help to get in or control their own destiny but have a difficult schedule to end the season.
8. LOS ANGELES CHARGERS (8-7)
Remaining games: vs Denver, at Las Vegas
Playoff chances: 35%
The Week 16 loss at Houston hurt the Chargers significantly. Instead of being 9-6 and controlling their playoff destiny, the Chargers now need to win two challenging games in the division and also need results to be in their benefit in other places – the Colts, Patriots, Dolphins, and Ravens all own tiebreakers over the Chargers and while the Bengals and Bills do not, they both need to falter significantly for those to be activated.
To make the playoffs, the Chargers must:
1. Win both remaining games and at least two of the following scenarios must occur:
a. Baltimore does not win out (Rams, Steelers)
b. Miami does not win out (Titans, Patriots)
c. New England loses out (Jaguars, Dolphins)
d. Indianapolis loses out (Raiders, Jaguars)
e. Buffalo loses out (Falcons, Jets)
f. Buffalo loses to the Jets and Patriots win out
The Ravens have been beset by injuries problems and while they play both games at home, they are difficult matchups against the Rams and their hated rivals, the Steelers. The Dolphins run a gauntlet to get in, having to travel to Nashville to take on the Titans and returning home to face the Patriots. Miami has had success against the Pats in the past, so that isn’t quite as daunting as it looks. Bottom line, the Chargers need to win and if they do, the path to the playoffs may just open back up for them.
The Chargers also have a path if they win one game
9. MIAMI DOLPHINS (8-7)
Remaining games: at Tennessee, vs New England
Playoff chances: 32%
The Dolphins control their own destiny – all they have to do is beat the Titans in Nashville and the Patriots at home. No sweat. Naturally, if they do not win these games, they need some help. They’re in the nine spot and not the five spot because it would be difficult to envision them running the table, seven game win streak notwithstanding. Neither the Titans nor the Patriots should expect an easy game
The Dolphins can win the AFC East if:
1. Miami wins out (Titans, Patriots)
2. Buffalo loses out (Falcons, Jets)
The Dolphins make the playoffs if they:
1. Win out
2. Win one game and the following:
a. No more than two of the contending AFC teams (excluding the division winners) finishes with 10 wins, or 9 wins and a tie for Pittsburgh.
b. Raiders do not beat the Chargers and lose to the Colts
c. Ravens do not beat the Steelers and lose to the Rams
Adding to the complexity is that the Ravens or Chargers would qualify with 9 wins depending on the order in which Miami wins once. If Miami beats Tennessee but loses to New England, Baltimore makes the playoffs. The other way around and it’s the Chargers that make it in.
10. NEW ORLEANS SAINTS (7-8)
Remaining games: vs Carolina, at Atlanta
Playoff chances: 37%
Out of this group, the Saints have the easiest path in terms of direct opposition. The Panthers have gone 2-10 after starting 3-0, and the whole team appears to have checked out. If the Falcons do not win in Buffalo, their chances of making the playoffs are gone, which leads to another potential lame duck game. This is fortunate for the Saints as they face a litany of injuries and COVID positives. The Saints started 5-2, stumbled, then won two in a row before last week’s uninspiring loss to the Dolphins. On the plus side, they have a strong conference record which will help them in tiebreakers.
The Saints make the playoffs if they:
1. Win out (Panthers, Falcons) and one the following scenarios occur:
a. Philadelphia and San Francisco do not win out
b. San Francisco wins out and Philadelphia does not win out
c. Philadelphia wins out, and San Francisco and Minnesota do not win out
2. The Saints can also make the playoffs with eight wins as long as Washington does not win out, either Philadelphia or San Francisco lose both games, and Minnesota and Atlanta do not win both their remaining games. New Orleans would also need to ensure that the loss was to the Panthers and not the Falcons in this scenario.
11. LAS VEGAS RAIDERS (8-7)
Remaining games: at Indianapolis, vs LA Chargers
Playoff chances: 17%
This is a tough schedule for the Raiders, rivaling the Dolphins last two games but, like the Dolphins, they have one advantage: if they win both games, they are in the playoffs (if the Raiders and Dolphins both win out, they’re each in at the expense of the Patriots). So even with this turbulent year, with the Jon Gruden controversy and subsequent resignation, and Henry Ruggs vehicular manslaughter charge, and (to a lesser extent) the ongoing call from some fans for the Raiders to replace QB Derek Carr with Marcus Mariota, the Raiders still have a legitimate shot at the postseason. They gotta win the games, but it’s better to have your fate in your own hands than to need to rely on someone else.
The Raiders can make the playoffs if they:
1. Win out (Colts, Chargers)
2. Beat the Chargers and:
12. BALTIMORE RAVENS (8-7)
Remaining games: vs LA Rams, vs Pittsburgh
Playoff chances: 22%
The Ravens find themselves at 8-7, just outside the playoffs seeds with 2 weeks to go, but what is a true picture of this team? They started off 5-1, with Lamar Jackson making a soft MVP push. However, the cracks were showing in the defensive unit that has been traditionally strong, but not this season, especially not in the secondary. Since that 5-1 start, the Ravens are 3-6, including losers for four straight as they head into a huge game at home against the Rams. There is a caveat with that four game losing streak: before they got thumped (for a second time this season) by the Bengals, the Ravens lost three games by four total points and in each of those games, the Ravens had a chance to convert a two-point conversion in the final two minutes that would’ve either won or tied the respective games. Even short-handed, even without Lamar Jackson, this team will not go out without a fight. But is the fight now too much for them?
The Ravens can win the division if:
1. Baltimore wins out (Rams, Steelers)
2. Cincinnati loses out (Chiefs, Browns)
The Ravens can otherwise make the playoffs if:
1. Baltimore wins out and two of the following scenarios occur:
a. Miami does not win out (Titans, Patriots)
b. LA Chargers do not win out (Broncos, Raiders)
c. New England loses out (Jaguars, Dolphins)
d. Buffalo loses out (Falcons, Jets)
e. Buffalo loses to the Jets and does not win the AFC East
f. Indianapolis loses out
g. Las Vegas loses out
As with the rest of the AFC North, the Chiefs-Bengals game has a seismic impact on the Ravens playoff hopes. The Ravens advantage over the Steelers and Browns is that they put the pressure on other teams by winning out and only need a couple situations to play themselves out. The thing working against the Ravens, they have to beat the Rams and likely without Lamar Jackson.
13. MINNESOTA VIKINGS (7-8)
Remaining games: at Green Bay, vs Chicago
Playoff chances: 9%
The Vikings are a difficult team to get a handle on, still only one game has been decided by more than a possession, and they’ve defeated the Packers and lost to the Lions. Sunday night’s game against those Packers though will be a challenge, but if they do not beat the Pack the playoffs become a pipe dream. The Vikings own some tiebreakers but not all, which means they’ll be very interested in how the other games shake out
The Vikings can make the playoffs if:
1. Minnesota wins out (Packers, Bears) and two of the following scenarios occur:
a. San Francisco does not win out (Texans, Rams)
b. Philadelphia does not win out (WFT, Cowboys)
c. New Orleans does not win out (Panthers, Falcons)
San Francisco owns the head-to-head tiebreaker (and all the other wild card contenders except New Orleans) and the Saints have a better strength-of-victory win percentage than Minnesota. Minnesota though wins a tiebreaker with the Falcons and Eagles. The Vikings do have a shot at getting in with eight wins which involves this specific scenario:
1. Minnesota wins one game (Packers or Bears)
2. Philadelphia loses out
3. Atlanta loses to the Bills and beats the Saints
4. New Orleans also loses to the Panthers
5. Washington loses to the Giants
14. PITTSBURGH STEELERS (7-7-1)
Remaining games: vs Cleveland, at Baltimore
Playoff chances: 12%
The future of likely HOF QB Ben Roethlisberger looks to be nearing the end – Big Ben is looking like a shell of his former self and the Steelers look to be on the verge of a rebuild which he likely does not want to endure as a 40 year old QB. That said, the Steelers still have a shot at making the playoffs, and they won’t have any pesky tiebreakers to deal with.
The Steelers can win the AFC North if:
1. Pittsburgh wins out (Browns, Ravens)
2. Cincinnati loses out (Chiefs, Browns)
The Steelers can make the playoffs otherwise if:
1. Pittsburgh wins out
2. Two or fewer wild card teams have 10 or more wins
The first domino to fall for the AFC North will be the Chiefs-Bengals game on Sunday. If the Bengals pull out that victory, they win the division and the rest of the division needs to hope on some level or miracles for a wild card spot, including the Steelers. For the Steelers, the games themselves are winnable, all the teams in the AFC North are good, though none of them are great and you can expect tight contests in each game regardless of the stakes for each team.
15. CLEVELAND BROWNS (7-8)
Remaining games: at Pittsburgh, vs Cincinnati
Playoff chances: 13%
The 7-8 Browns are 12th in the AFC standings but still have a legitimate shot at the playoffs, if only because the rest of the division is separated only by two games and some of the scenarios for other teams are definitely achievable.
The Browns can win the AFC North if:
1. Cleveland wins out (Steelers, Bengals)
2. Cincinnati also loses to the Chiefs
3. Baltimore loses at least one game (Rams, Steelers)
With Cleveland’s earlier victory over the Bengals and the Ravens’ poor divisional record, the Browns hold tiebreakers over both. A Browns win over the Steelers on Monday night would eliminate Pittsburgh. While Cincinnati and Baltimore both play at home this weekend, their matchups are very difficult. Does this mean the Browns will win out and take the North? If this weekend goes their way, they’ll reason for confidence in Week 18 after they crushed Cincinnati at home in Week 9.
LONGSHOTS: Washington, Atlanta, Denver
The longshots are teams that are mathematically in the playoff race, but need wins by them, losses by a lot of others, and advanced calculus to make it into the playoffs. If the Broncos make the playoffs, beers are on me to anyone who reads this.
16. WASHINGTON (6-9)
Remaining games: vs Philadelphia, at NY Giants
Playoff chances: 7%
Despite their recent implosion, Washington still has a better shot at the playoffs than the Falcons and Broncos. One reason is that their games are somewhat easier in terms of strength of opponent. The Eagles are a tough out, but the Giants are playing out the string and a playoff team should be able to beat them regardless.
8-9 Washington would have tiebreaker advantages over every other NFC, which means their playoff scenario is:
1. Beat the Eagles and Giants
2. All other contenders, except one, finish 8-9 or worse. Which means at least four of the following five must take place:
a. Philadelphia also loses to the Cowboys in Week 18
b. San Francisco loses out (Texans, Rams)
c. Minnesota does not win out (Packers, Bears)
d. Atlanta does not win out (Bills, Saints)
e. New Orleans does not win out (Panthers, Falcons)
The first scenario (win out and Philly loses to Dallas) is somewhat plausible – if Dallas is still jockeying for seeding, going all out to beat the Eagles would be desirable for them. San Francisco likely beats the Texans at home this weekend, which means they’re looking for the Vikings, Falcons, and Saints to all lose at least one game. The Saints are the one to watch for, as the Panthers have little to play for and, if the Falcons lose to the Bills this weekend, they’ll also only be playing for pride. Regardless of what happens in other games, Washington also has to take care of business, which is easier said than done, as they are riding a three-game losing streak and have one of the worst point differentials in the NFC.
17. ATLANTA FALCONS (7-8)
Remaining games: at Buffalo, vs New Orleans
Playoff chances: 3%
Atlanta has a better record than Washington but worse odds. The reason: Atlanta is just 4-7 in conference play – the best they can do is 5-7, and they lost to both the Niners and Eagles, eliminating another in, and means that an 8-9 Falcons are guaranteed to miss the playoffs (the Niners and Eagles can do no worse than that). The Falcons could finish as high as 6th in the NFC if everything goes their way, but they would need to be the only NFC team to finish 9-8. The scenarios to make it in at all are:
1. Beat the Bills and Saints
2. Have at least two of the following scenarios happen:
a. San Francisco loses out (Texans, Rams)
b. Philadelphia loses out (WFT, Cowboys)
c. Vikings lose one of their remaining games (Packers, Bears)
If the Falcons win out and two of those scenarios occur, the Falcons are seventh in the NFC, if all three occur, the Falcons are sixth.
18. DENVER BRONCOS (7-8)
Remaining games: at LA Chargers, vs Kansas City
Playoff chances: <0.1%
In 18th and last place are the Denver Broncos. The Broncos have one very specific path to the postseason in which all criteria below must be met:
1. Beat the Chargers and Chiefs
2. Las Vegas must lose out (Colts, Chargers)
3. Baltimore must lose to the Rams and beat the Steelers
4. Cleveland must beat the Steelers and lose to the Bengals
5. Miami must lose out (Titans, Patriots)
The Broncos would win the tiebreaker over the Chargers and no other team would be 9-8. Denver would sneak in if all TEN results happen in their favour. That would be one hell of a parlay.